How to Screen Tenants Without Discriminating

Tenant screening is one of the most important aspects of property management. It ensures that landlords find responsible, reliable, and trustworthy individuals to rent their properties, which in turn helps maintain the value of the rental and avoid problematic situations. However, tenant screening can be a delicate process. Landlords must balance the need for a thorough vetting process with the legal requirement to avoid discrimination. The Fair Housing Act (FHA) in the United States, along with various state and local laws, prohibits landlords from discriminating against tenants based on certain protected characteristics.

In this article, we will explore how to screen tenants effectively while ensuring that the process is non-discriminatory. We’ll examine best practices for screening tenants, legal requirements, and how to make objective decisions that protect both you as a landlord and the rights of prospective tenants.

Understanding Fair Housing Laws

Buy Me A Coffee

Before diving into how to screen tenants without discriminating, it is crucial to understand what discrimination is and the laws that govern the tenant screening process.

The Fair Housing Act (FHA), which was passed in 1968 in the United States, prohibits discrimination in housing based on race, color, religion, sex, familial status, national origin, or disability. These protected classes are central to ensuring that all people have an equal opportunity to rent or buy housing without facing unfair treatment. In addition to the FHA, some states and municipalities have expanded their own protections to include categories like sexual orientation, gender identity, marital status, or source of income.

Discrimination in the tenant screening process can occur in several ways, such as:

Refusing to rent to someone based on their race, religion, or national origin.
Imposing different rental terms or conditions for tenants based on protected categories.
Using biased language or behavior that may discourage certain groups from applying.
Implementing policies that disproportionately affect people in a protected class, even if the policies seem neutral at first glance.

It’s important to recognize that unintentional discrimination can also occur, especially if landlords are not familiar with the laws or if they rely on subjective, biased practices. The goal is to adopt a tenant screening process that is consistent, objective, and compliant with all legal requirements.

Best Practices for Non-Discriminatory Tenant Screening

1. Develop a Clear and Consistent Screening Policy

The first step in creating a non-discriminatory tenant screening process is to develop a clear and consistent set of criteria that will be applied to all applicants. This helps ensure that you are evaluating each applicant on the same standards and reduces the likelihood of bias or discrimination. Your screening policy should be based on objective factors that are directly related to a tenant’s ability to meet their rental obligations.

Your screening criteria should include:

Income Requirements: Typically, landlords require that tenants earn a certain amount of income to ensure they can afford the rent. A common guideline is that tenants should earn at least three times the rent in gross monthly income.
Credit History: A tenant’s credit score can give you insight into their financial responsibility. You may set a minimum credit score requirement, but avoid using credit history as the sole deciding factor.
Rental History: Past rental history can provide valuable information about how well a tenant pays rent and maintains their living space. Landlords often contact previous landlords to ask about the tenant’s payment history, property upkeep, and behavior.
Criminal Background: Some landlords conduct criminal background checks to ensure safety on the property. However, criminal background checks should be used carefully to avoid disproportionately excluding certain groups. It’s important to avoid blanket policies that automatically reject tenants with a criminal record.
Employment History: Stable employment history is often considered an indicator of financial stability. However, it’s essential not to discriminate against applicants who may have gaps in employment for legitimate reasons (e.g., a stay-at-home parent or someone transitioning between jobs).

Once you have established these criteria, ensure that they are applied uniformly to all applicants. This reduces the chance of discrimination and reinforces the importance of treating all applicants equally.

2. Use Fair and Transparent Language in Your Advertising

One way discrimination can seep into the screening process is through biased or exclusionary language in advertising. When listing a rental property, landlords must be mindful of the language they use. For example, phrases such as “no kids” or “single professionals only” could be seen as discriminatory because they exclude certain groups based on familial status or other protected categories.

Here are a few tips for creating non-discriminatory rental advertisements:

Avoid terms that imply any preference for certain groups, such as “ideal for single tenants” or “perfect for young professionals.”
Focus on the qualities of the rental property itself, such as the number of bedrooms, amenities, and location.
If you want to highlight specific characteristics (e.g., “no pets”), ensure that these restrictions are clearly tied to the property’s specific needs or your personal policies, rather than making generalizations that could alienate certain groups.

Transparency is also key when advertising rental properties. Always ensure that applicants know exactly what the screening criteria are and what will be expected of them.

3. Treat All Applicants Equally

One of the simplest ways to avoid discrimination during tenant screening is to treat all applicants equally. This means applying the same screening criteria to everyone, regardless of their race, religion, gender, or any other protected class. Treating applicants equally does not mean that you have to accept everyone who applies, but you should assess each applicant using the same objective standards.

To ensure fairness, it can be helpful to:

Keep a detailed record of the decisions made for each applicant.
Avoid making subjective or emotionally charged decisions. For example, if an applicant seems “difficult” but meets all your criteria, it is important to document the reason for rejection without resorting to personal biases.
Be mindful of your own biases and make a conscious effort to remain objective. Sometimes our own unconscious biases can influence our decision-making, so it’s essential to remain aware of that tendency.

Training staff involved in the tenant screening process is another effective way to minimize discriminatory practices. Everyone who is part of the decision-making process should understand the importance of non-discrimination and the legal requirements that govern the screening process.

4. Be Cautious with Criminal Background Checks

Conducting criminal background checks is a common part of tenant screening, but this practice can be fraught with potential discrimination if not done carefully. While landlords have a legitimate interest in ensuring the safety and security of their tenants, overly broad criminal background checks can disproportionately impact certain racial or ethnic groups. For example, Black and Latino communities have been shown to experience higher arrest rates, which could lead to discrimination if those records are used in a blanket decision-making process.

Here are a few tips to ensure that criminal background checks are used fairly:

Evaluate the nature and severity of any criminal offenses. Consider factors such as how long ago the offense occurred, whether the applicant has demonstrated rehabilitation, and the relevance of the crime to their ability to be a responsible tenant.
Avoid automatic rejection based on a criminal record. Instead, create a case-by-case evaluation system that considers the circumstances surrounding the conviction.
If your decision is based on criminal history, make sure to inform the applicant of their rights. In some states, tenants have the right to appeal or explain criminal history issues.

5. Provide Reasonable Accommodations for Disabled Tenants

The Fair Housing Act also requires landlords to make reasonable accommodations for tenants with disabilities. This includes things like allowing service animals in a property that otherwise has a no-pets policy or modifying a unit to make it accessible.

Landlords are not required to make accommodations that would impose an undue financial or administrative burden on them, but they must engage in an interactive process with tenants to find solutions that work for both parties. Reasonable accommodations could also include allowing tenants extra time to pay rent or modifying policies to address specific needs.

To avoid discrimination, landlords should:

Inform tenants about their right to request reasonable accommodations.
Respond to accommodation requests promptly and engage in discussions to find appropriate solutions.
Make sure that any accommodation requests are handled confidentially to avoid violating the tenant’s privacy.

6. Document Everything

Finally, always keep a thorough record of your tenant screening process. Documenting your actions and decisions ensures that you can defend yourself in the event of a dispute. If a rejected tenant claims discrimination, you will have evidence to show that you followed a fair, consistent process in evaluating their application.

Keep records of:

The rental application.
Communication with the tenant.
The reasons for approving or rejecting the applicant.
Background checks, credit reports, and any other relevant information.

Being transparent and documenting your actions provides clarity and shows that you are following fair and non-discriminatory practices.

Conclusion

Screening tenants without discrimination is not just a legal requirement but also a moral obligation that ensures fair and equal access to housing. By following best practices such as developing clear, consistent policies, using objective criteria, and being mindful of legal protections, landlords can reduce the risk of discrimination and create a more inclusive and fair renting process.

The key is to treat every applicant with respect, apply the same standards to all, and ensure that decisions are based on objective factors relevant to the tenant’s ability to fulfill their responsibilities as a renter. By doing so, landlords not only comply with the law but also contribute to building communities that are welcoming and equitable for all.